One of the popular ideas floating around is the flat tax, which is the idea that everyone should pay a flat percentage of their income. There are variations on the flat tax, and some even include limited deductions for charity, as well as some allowance for those who might be especially poor.
However, the version that many of the local Mormons prefer is a straight percentage, tithing-style.
|Via Path To God|
Tithing and Sacrifice
Recently, someone asked me if I thought what I was paying in taxes was "fair" considering we moved up a tax bracket for 2012.
"Wouldn't you rather go to a flat tax? Wouldn't it be fairer if you didn't pay any more of your income than someone in a lower tax bracket?"
While I think "fair" is an extremely subjective term, and it's not really something that you can quantify, I ignored my issues with the terminology and said, "I don't think that would be fairer at all. Someone who makes less than I do would have a harder time paying that same percentage."
And then, because we're both Mormon, he pulled out what he figured was his trump:
"But what about tithing? Isn't that fair?"
"No, not really," I replied.
Widened eyes. Stunned silence.
"Look at my income," I said motioning to the computer screen. "And then consider someone who makes $30,000 a year."
After I pay my 10% -- and even after I pay my fast offerings, and into the ward missionary fund -- I still have plenty of money left over to pay the bills and do the things I want. However, someone who makes $30,000 misses that $3,000 paid in tithing more than I miss the money I pay. That tithing comes out of discretionary spending. Even where I live, with a low cost of living, someone making $20,000 or $30,000 would be hard-pressed to enjoy a good quality of life, able to meet obligations. Paying tithing at that income level is a true sacrifice in a way that paying 10% (or more for other offerings) isn't for me.
"So you really think that they sacrifice more than you to pay tithing?"
"Yes," I said. Unequivocally.
Take a moment and consider the parable of the widow's mites.
Besides, even tithing isn't the "perfect" law. From the Mormon perspective, tithing is a preparatory thing. Something else is coming, and it's going to be all about giving more if you have more.